FATHERLAND. Directed by Pawel Palikowski. Starring Sandra Huller, Hanns Zischler, August Diehl, Joachim Meyerhoff and David Striesow. Rated PG. Parental guidance recommended for younger audiences, especially. 82 min.
Review by Peter W Sheehan, Jesuit Media Australia
This 2026 biographical film was selected as the Polish entry for Best International Feature film at the 99th Academy Awards. The film centers on the relationship between a writer, Thomas Mann and his daughter, Erika, and it captures eyewitness testimonies of people who were involved in real life dramatic events.

The film begins in 1949 with Klaus Mann (August Diehl) telephoning his sister Erika (Sandra Huller) Erika invites Klaus to join her and her father Thomas Mann (Hans Zischler) to return to Germany after spending years in exile in the United States.
Thomas Mann won the Nobel Prize for Literature and fled Germany after the Nazis took power in 1933. Thomas receives letters stating he is a traitor to the Fatherland which Erika hands to the CIA. Erika is then told that her brother, Klaus, has committed suicide, and Thomas Mann decides to continue his journey to receive his prize. This is a very revealing film about postwar Germany and those deeply affected by what happened.
The Director of the movie, Pawel Palikowski is in full command of the medium of Cinema. He has directed a powerful film about exile, betrayal and perception of the impossibility for some to go “home”. It is a wonderful movie, but necessarily and tragically grim. Erika deeply misses her brother. She is guilty about what has happened and is deeply affected by Thomas’ determination to continue with his tour. She has sensed that her brother sold out to the nazis and massive conflict has affected her deeply.
The direction of the movie is taut and well-disciplined and offers no easy answers to the moral issues it raises. Erika can’t accept Thomas continuing his tour and the film dramatically addresses the personal anguish of people suffering from terrible memories, and the movies’ Black and white photography accentuates the tragedy of what has and is occurring. The force of Huller’s acting is exceptional. It was amply evident in the awarded brilliance of “The Anatomy of a Fall” and “Zone of interest”, both 2023 films of great distinction which featured her skills.
All the characters in this film are affected by what has occurred. The acting of Erika and Klaus exactly captures the in-effectiveness of Government and political systems. The film ends with a beautiful, unsettling rendition of Bach’s “Jesu, Joy of Man’s desiring” which highlights the power of artists and thinkers that resides in the devotion being expressed.
Reviewed by Peter Sheehan, an Associate of Jesuit Media

